Welcome to Mary Carroll’s, your quintessential Irish pub nestled in the heart of Babylon, New York. Located at 121 Deer Park Ave, this establishment radiates authenticity and charm, making it the perfect spot for both casual hangouts and lively gatherings. Owner Connor ensures a warm atmosphere, along with his team, including well-loved bartenders like Jacky, Benny, Francis, and Dan, who are always ready to serve up a cold pint with a smile.

Mary Carroll’s offers a delectable menu that goes beyond typical bar fare, showcasing an array of thoughtfully crafted dishes that invite comfort and satisfaction. Begin your culinary journey with the Giant Pretzel served with a mouthwatering three cheese beer dip, or indulge in the crispy Fried Pickles—each appetizer is not merely an afterthought but a delightful part of your dining experience. For those craving something vibrant and filling, the Ultimate Nachos loaded with ground beef, cheese, and more, will undoubtedly hit the mark.

The wings here come in both small and large portions, allowing you to customize your experience with flavorful sauces ranging from Hot to Whiskey BBQ. And don’t miss the opportunity to craft your own burger! The Build Your Own burger option lets you choose your toppings—from crispy bacon to creamy avocado—even allowing for a veggie twist with the Quinoa Black Bean Veggie Patty. Exploring the unique flavors of the Hawaiian LTO Burger, featuring grilled pineapple and thick candied bacon, is a must-try for burger aficionados.

As Avery, one of our delighted patrons, emphasized, Mary Carroll’s isn’t just another Irish pub; it thrives on its true Irish ownership, ensuring quality food and an unparalleled atmosphere. The backyard space is particularly inviting on sunny days, making it an ideal location for families and friends alike. Whether you’re dining in, ordering takeout, or enjoying delivery as Santino does, the experience remains consistently rewarding. And if you’re looking for a fun night out, the vibrant ambiance filled with laughter and camaraderie will surely make your visit memorable.

With comfort food at fair prices and swift service—even on busy Friday nights—Mary Carroll’s stands as a beloved staple in Babylon’s culinary scene. You won't just be savoring dishes; you'll be part of a community that values good food, great drinks, and lasting friendships. So, come on down, raise a glass, and enjoy what makes Mary Carroll’s a standout destination in this charming neighborhood!